Sheepshead Bay has a variety of fishing in Rockaway Inlet. Within Rockaway Inlet, there are
- Fluke
- Flounder
- Stripe Bass
- Blue Fish
- Porgies
- Weakfish
- Black Fish
- Sea Bass
Through out the fishing season members organize various fishing tournaments open to the membership. After the tournament, there is a rod and reel raffle, amongst other prizes and a barbecue.